This post may contain affiliate links, to learn more about them, check out our Disclosure.
When creating skin care products, ensuring their safety and longevity is essential. Without proper preservatives, water-based products become breeding grounds for bacteria, mold, and yeast. But how do you choose the right preservative? Understanding preservatives for skin care products, their effectiveness, and how they interact with different formulations is key to making high-quality, safe products.
Why Are Preservatives Necessary?
Many DIY and small-batch skincare formulators hesitate to use preservatives, fearing harsh chemicals. However, even the most natural product can become unsafe if microbes grow in it. Preservatives help:
- Prevent bacterial, yeast, and mold contamination
- Extend shelf life
- Ensure product safety for consumers
- Maintain the integrity of emulsions and formulations
Any product containing water, aloe, hydrosols, or botanical extracts needs a preservative. Oil-based products generally don’t require preservatives but may benefit from antioxidants like Vitamin E to slow oxidation.
Understanding pH and Preservative Effectiveness
One crucial factor in choosing preservatives is your product’s pH level. Some preservatives work best in acidic environments, while others are effective in a broader pH range.
For example:
- Germaben II works best in pH 3.0–7.0, making it ideal for lotions and creams.
- Optiphen Plus is effective at pH ≤6.0, which is suitable for facial serums and body butters.
- Euxyl® K 900 works in pH 2.0–12.0, offering broad-spectrum protection for various formulations.
Testing your product’s pH with test strips or a pH meter ensures your preservative will function properly.
Natural vs. Synthetic Preservatives: What’s the Difference?
Preservatives for skin care products fall into two categories: natural and synthetic.
Natural Preservatives
Natural preservatives are derived from plants, minerals, or fermentation processes. While they are eco-friendly, they often require blending with other natural preservatives to offer full-spectrum protection. Examples include:
- Leucidal Liquid SF (Radish Root Ferment) – Effective against bacteria, often combined with AMTicide Coconut for mold protection.
- Glucono Delta Lactone (GDL) – A natural chelator that helps other preservatives function more effectively.
- Sorbic Acid & Benzoic Acid – Inhibit mold and yeast but need to be used at the correct pH.
Synthetic Preservatives
Synthetic preservatives often provide more broad-spectrum protection with minimal usage rates. These include:
- Phenoxyethanol – Common in natural formulations, effective against bacteria and fungi.
- Liquid Germall Plus – Works well in water-based products with a pH of 3.0–8.0.
- Euxyl® K 903 – A liquid preservative great for emulsions and effective against bacteria and yeast.
While some synthetic preservatives like DMDM Hydantoin are formaldehyde-releasing, many widely used preservatives are free from harmful chemicals.
Combining Preservatives for Full-Spectrum Protection
Most natural preservatives don’t offer broad-spectrum protection alone. Combining multiple preservatives ensures complete microbial defense.
For example:
- Leucidal Liquid SF (bacteria protection) + AMTicide Coconut (mold & yeast protection)
- Glucono Delta Lactone + Sorbic Acid for a natural broad-spectrum blend
Blending preservatives ensures your product remains safe, effective, and free from microbial contamination.
How to Choose the Right Preservative
When selecting preservatives for skin care products, consider:
Natural vs. synthetic preference – Decide based on your formulation goals and target audience.
Product type – Is it water-based, oil-based, or an emulsion?
pH compatibility – Ensure your preservative is effective within your formulation’s pH range.
Broad-spectrum protection – Does it protect against bacteria, yeast, and mold?
| Preservative | Application | Natural/Synthetic | pH Range | Suitable for Water/Oil-Based Products | Contains Phthalates/Formaldehyde |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phenoxyethanol | Broad-spectrum preservative effective against bacteria and fungi. | Synthetic | 3.0-10.0 | Water Based | No |
| Euxyl® K 900 | Effective against bacteria, yeast, and mold. | Synthetic | 2.0-12.0 | Water Based | NO |
| Euxyl® K 903 | Suitable for emulsions, effective against bacteria and yeast. | Synthetic | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| Leucidal Liquid | Derived from fermented radish root, effective against bacteria. | Natural | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| Leucidal Liquid SF | Broad-spectrum activity, suitable for sensitive skin products. | Natural | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| Leucidal Liquid SF MAX | Enhanced antimicrobial properties. | Natural | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| NeoDefend | Broad-spectrum protection in cosmetic formulations. | Synthetic | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| AMTicide Coconut | Derived from coconut, effective against yeast and mold. | Natural | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| Biguanide 20 | Effective against bacteria, yeast, and mold. | Synthetic | 3.0-10.0 | Water Based | No |
| Glucono Delta Lactone (GDL) | Preservative and chelating agent, often used with other preservatives. | Natural | 3.0-5.0 | Water Based | No |
| Sorbic Acid | Inhibits fungal growth | Natural | 2.0-6.5 | Water Based | No |
| Benzoic Acid | Used as a preservative, especially in acidic formulations. | Natural | 2.0-5.0 | Water Based | No |
| Liquid Germall Plus | Preserves foaming washes and high water content formulations. | Synthetic | 3.0-8.0 | Water Based | No |
| Optiphen Plus | Preserves water and oil-based products with a pH below 6.0. | Synthetic | ≤6.0 | Water and oil-based | No |
| DMDM Hydantoin | Effective in products with a pH range of 3–9. | Synthetic | 3.0-9.0 | Water Based | No |
| Germaben II | Preserves products made with less than 25% oils; effective against bacteria, yeast, and mold. | Synthetic | 3.0-7.0 | Water Based | No |
Note: The information provided is based on available data from Lotioncrafter, Bramble Berry, and Wholesale Supplies Plus. It’s essential to review each preservative’s technical data sheet and safety information to ensure suitability for your specific formulations.
Using the right preservative is essential for creating safe, long-lasting skin care products. While natural preservatives are appealing, they often require blending for complete protection. Understanding your product’s pH and choosing the best preservative ensures you provide high-quality products that remain free from harmful microbial growth.
Want to know more about emulsifiers? Check out our Guide to Emulsifiers in Skin Care. Want more tutorials? Follow us on YouTube!
